Store LocatorAccess Pass
BUY MORE, SAVE MORE. 25% OFF | 30% OFF ORDERS OVER $65
Use code SAVENOW
  1. MLB
  2. Trading Cards
  3. $40 to $60
1 - 72 of 117
Trading Cards
Arizona DiamondbacksAtlanta BravesBaltimore OriolesBoston Red SoxChicago CubsDetroit TigersHouston AstrosLos Angeles AngelsLos Angeles DodgersMilwaukee BrewersNew York MetsNew York YankeesPhiladelphia PhilliesSeattle MarinersSt. Louis CardinalsTexas Rangers
117 Items
Arizona DiamondbacksAtlanta BravesBaltimore OriolesBoston Red SoxChicago CubsDetroit TigersHouston AstrosLos Angeles AngelsLos Angeles DodgersMilwaukee BrewersNew York MetsNew York YankeesPhiladelphia PhilliesSeattle MarinersSt. Louis CardinalsTexas Rangers
$44.99 with code
$59.99
Shohei Ohtani, Yoshinobu Yamamoto and Roki Sasaki Los Angeles Dodgers 2025 Topps Now Debut As Dodgers Teammates In Tokyo Series #7 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Most Popular in Collectibles & Memorabilia
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels 2023 Topps Throwback Thursday #122 CGC Authenticated 10 Card
Most Popular in Collectibles & Memorabilia
$44.99 with code
$59.99
Aaron Judge New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 1st Career 3-HR Game, 34th in Yankee History #754 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Paul Skenes, Elly De La Cruz and Gunnar Henderson 2025 Topps Now MLB The Show 25 Cover Athletes Revealed #OS-17 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Most Popular in Collectibles & Memorabilia
$44.99 with code
$59.99
Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Dodgers 2025 Topps Now Reigning NL MVP Launches His 1st HR Of 2025 #5 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$44.99 with code
$59.99
Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Dodgers 2025 Topps Now Bobblehead Night Walk-Off HR Caps Record 8-0 Start #35 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels 2023 Topps Now 1st Player In MLB History With 40 HR & 10 Wins #683 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Most Popular in Collectibles & Memorabilia
$44.99 with code
$59.99
Aaron Judge New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Fastest to 250 Career HR in MLB History #800 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
New York Yankees 2024 Topps Now Yankees Honor 2009 World Series Championship Team 08.24.24 #590 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Matt Shaw Chicago Cubs 2025 Topps Now Cubs Top Prospect Smashes 1st Career Home Run #21 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Ronald Acuna Jr. Atlanta Braves 2023 Topps Now 5th Ever 40/40 Season #903 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
David Ortiz Boston Red Sox 2016 Topps Now Sets Record for Most HR's in Final Season #482 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$44.99 with code
$59.99
LeBron James & Mookie Betts 2023 Topps Now Salute to Greatness #736 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Aaron Judge New York Yankees 2024 Topps Now 1st HR Of 2024 Postseason Seals 2-0 ALCS Lead #837 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Roki Sasaki Los Angeles Dodgers 2024 Topps Now Japanese Fireballer Signs With Dodgers #OS-13 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Roki Sasaki Los Angeles Dodgers 2024 Topps Now Dodgers Introduce Prized International Signing #OS-16 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels 2023 Topps Now Superstar Does It All In Historic 4 Hit Game #294 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Most Popular in Collectibles & Memorabilia
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Corbin Carroll Arizona Diamondbacks 2023 Topps Now 1st Rookie in MLB History with 25 HR & 50 SB #898 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$59.99
J.T. Realmuto Philadelphia Phillies 2023 Topps Now Most Postseason HRs By A Phillies Catcher #982 CGC Authenticated 10 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Aaron Judge New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 2023 MLB All-Star Game Selection - AL #ASG-AJ BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Cam Smith Houston Astros 2025 Topps Now Astros Top Prospect Collects Hit in MLB Debut #9 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Gunnar Henderson Baltimore Orioles 2023 Topps Throwback Thursdays 89 Topps Future Stars #107 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
J.T. Realmuto Philadelphia Phillies 2023 Topps Now Hit for Cycle #434 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Juan Soto New York Yankees 2024 Topps Now Youngest Player To Homer Against All 30 MLB Teams #542 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels 2023 Topps Now League Lead Tying 43rd HR of 2023 is Grand Slam #727 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Jackson Holliday and Gunnar Henderson Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps Now Orioles Stars Go Yard in the Same Inning #513 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$44.99 with code
$59.99
Aaron Judge New York Yankees 2024 Topps Throwback Thursday 90 Topps Ames All- Stars #95 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Pete Alonso New York Mets 2023 Topps Now 1st Mets Player with Four 35+ HR Seasons #682 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Gerrit Cole New York Yankees 2020 Topps Now Best of Topps Now #BTN-8 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Pete Alonso New York Mets 2023 Topps Now 10th All-time Mets RBI List #713 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Collects 1st Hit & Runs Into Yankees Record Book #22 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 1st Career Walk-Off RBI Seals Win Over Orioles #337 CGC Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Yankees Rookie Blast 1st Career Grand Slam #264 CGC Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Brett Baty New York Mets 2022 Topps Now Slugs Two-Run Homer In 1st Career MLB At-Bat #729 CGC Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees 2024 Topps Now Rookie Cup Team #RC1 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$44.99 with code
$59.99
Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels 2023 Topps Now Fastest To Reach 40 HRs & 15 SBs In A Season #672 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels 2023 Topps Throwback Thursday #122 CGC Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Pete Alonso New York Mets 2023 Topps Now Walk-Off #311 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$44.99 with code
$59.99
Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels 2023 Topps Now 2023 MLB All-Star Game Selection - AL #ASG-SO BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2023 Topps Now 2023 MLB All-Star Game Selection - AL #ASG-JR BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Leads Off & Hits 1st MLB HR in 1st Inning #119 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
J.T. Realmuto Philadelphia Phillies 2023 Topps Now Most Postseason HRs By A Catcher #982 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Corbin Carroll Arizona Diamondbacks 2023 Topps Throwback Thursdays '89 Topps Future Stars #108 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Brett Baty New York Mets 2022 Topps Now 2-Run Homer in 1st at Bat #729 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Mookie Betts Los Angeles Dodgers 2024 Topps TBT 90 Topps Ames All-Stars #96 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Throwback Thursdays '89 Topps Future Stars #106 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Matt Olson Atlanta Braves 2023 Topps Now Sets Braves Single-Season Record with 52nd HR #874 CGC Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Kristian Campbell Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now 22 Year Old Prospect Notches 1st Hit in MLB Debut #11 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Colt Keith Detroit Tigers 2024 Topps Now 2024 Rookie Cup Team #RC3 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Roki Sasaki Los Angeles Dodgers 2025 Topps Now Anticipated MLB Debut Comes In Home Country #3 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 1st HR at Yankee Stadium #827 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Roki Sasaki Los Angeles Dodgers 2025 Topps Now Dodgers Introduce Prized International Signing #OS-16 CGC Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Josh Jung Texas Rangers 2023 Topps Now ASG #ASG-JJ BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Nolan Arenado St. Louis Cardinals 2023 Topps Now 1,000 RBI #312 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Colton Cowser Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps Now 2024 Rookie Cup Team #RC8 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Ronny Mauricio New York Mets 2023 Topps Now Call-Up Blue #858 #/49 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Yankees Top Prospect Makes His Big League Debut #2 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Leads Off & Hits 1st MLB HR In 1st Inning #119 CGC Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now "The Martian" Takes Flight With HR In MLB Debut #798 CGC Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Juan Soto New York Yankees 2024 Topps Now Youngest Player To Homer Against All 30 MLB Teams #542 CGC Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Matt Shaw Chicago Cubs 2025 Topps Now 1st MLB Hit & Run Scored For Top Cubs Prospect #6 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now 1st Opening Day Leadoff HR in Yankees History #8 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees 2024 Topps Now MLB Rookie Cup Team Pearl #RC-1 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Juan Soto New York Mets 2025 Topps Now 1st Home Run with Mets Is A Majestic Moonshot #17 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Carson Kelly Chicago Cubs 2025 Topps Now 1st Cubs Cycle Since 1993 Fuels Blowout Win #ODB2 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Almost Gone!
$44.99 with code
$59.99
DNU Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Joins Rare Company With 1st HR At Yankee Stadium #827 CGC Authenticated 10 Card
Almost Gone!
$44.99 with code
$59.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Collects 1st Hit & Runs Into Yankees Record Book #22 CGC Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Yankees Rookie Blast 1st Career Grand Slam #264 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Ronny Mauricio New York Mets 2023 Topps Now Call-Up Hit #796 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Ronny Mauricio New York Mets 2023 Topps Now Call-Up #858 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Adley Rutschman Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps TBT 90 Topps Ames All-Stars #94 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$37.49 with code
$49.99
Matt Olson Atlanta Braves 2023 Topps Now Sets Braves Single Season Record with 52 HR #874 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Arizona DiamondbacksAtlanta BravesBaltimore OriolesBoston Red SoxChicago CubsDetroit TigersHouston AstrosLos Angeles AngelsLos Angeles DodgersMilwaukee BrewersNew York MetsNew York YankeesPhiladelphia PhilliesSeattle MarinersSt. Louis CardinalsTexas Rangers

Top MLB Collections